Course Probes 2026 Election Threats in Real Time
While midterm election campaigns play out across the country, students in a Yale Law School classroom this fall have been wrestling with questions about the 2026 election that are not only academic.
Their questions as Election Day approaches: how can this election — and all U.S. elections — be truly free and fair? How did we get to a place where this is an issue? And what can we do going forward? These and related issues are being hashed out in real time in “Protecting the 2026 Election,” a course co-taught by Sterling Professor of Law Robert Post ’77.
Mounting concerns about the integrity of the midterm elections inspired Post to create the course. He cites issues including the attempted seizure of states’ voting lists, pressures from the White House on the U.S. Postal Service to implement an executive order restricting voting by mail, and proposals to send ICE agents to polling places — a combination of threats Post says was unheard of in a midterm U.S. election until this year.
“I can’t remember the federal government making sustained efforts to intervene in state-run elections in the ways it has in this election,” Post said.
To consider the election from multiple angles, Post enlisted two co-teachers to provide a balance of academic and real-world perspectives: Visiting Professor Richard Pildes and Visiting Lecturer Tim Collins.
Pildes, an NYU Law professor, is the nation’s most cited scholar on election law and a co-author of an influential 1998 book that created a new field of study concerning elections. Collins, CEO of a private equity and financial services firm, contributes insights about political conversations taking place “in the boardrooms and in the back halls,” according to Post. Collins has served on public company boards in several countries, where he interacts with political leaders.
For Post, the course is not only an opportunity to learn about the practical politics of elections and how they relate to election law. It is also a chance to learn what resources are available if threats to the election materialize.
“These are very important things to know,” Post said. “You can’t get them from textbooks. You have to get them from the people who are actually on the front lines.”
For that perspective, Post and his co-teachers lined up a series of bipartisan guest speakers whose work, if not names, will be familiar to many who follow the news or have closely watched efforts to protect elections. They included current and former elected officials, activists, and lawyers working in policy and in practice for election-related organizations.
You can’t get them from textbooks. You have to get them from the people who are actually on the front lines.”
—Professor Robert Post on resources for protecting elections
The course covers issues both political and technical. A reading for an early class delved into the Supreme Court case that produced the “one person, one vote” standard, or the requirement that voting districts have roughly the same number of people so that each vote has equal weight. A seemingly simple question drove the discussion: What is the function of elections?
Second-year student Anna Brent-Levenstein was struck by one answer: that a purpose of elections is to create a system that gives the people who didn’t win the greatest sense of fairness. When elections work, according to this reasoning, voters on the losing side still believe their side can win the next election. But, she learned, that safeguard is being eroded when both political parties frame every election as existential.
The conversation also covered the value of accountability and representation, along with buy-in and the importance of each citizen having a stake in the direction of the government and the country.
“That, to me, is something we still struggle with — and need to continue working towards,” second-year student Milan Vivanco said.
Some classes paired prominent scholars with public figures. In one class, Yale theologian Miroslav Volf joined former South Carolina Gov. David Muldrow Beasley for a conversation about the role of religion in U.S. politics. Beasley calls himself “the last living casualty of the Civil War.” He later went on to lead the United Nations World Food Programme, which under his guidance received a Nobel Prize. He discussed how religion came into play as the defining issue of his political career.
During his first and only term as governor in 1996, Beasley, a Republican, proposed taking down the Confederate flag that flew over the South Carolina State House and moving it to another flagpole on capitol grounds. The proposal likely cost him reelection in 1998. Two years later, however, the state legislature approved Beasley’s plan to relocate the flag. It was removed from state house grounds completely in 2015.
Volf started the conversation by comparing “thick” and “thin” religion: faith deeply held and practiced in daily life versus a less personally demanding form that, especially in politics, is a marker of cultural identity.
Beasley described how in his political life, he was able to persuade people by tapping into “thick” religion. He said he found that people would change their stance when he brought up what their faith truly demanded, like the Christian command to “love thy enemy.”
“It's amazing what happens when you touch inside someone's heart,” Beasley said, adding that the effect was the same in his later U.N. work, regardless of the country or religion. “The interesting thing is, it applies the same all over the world.”
The conversation on religion in politics resonated with LL.M. student Gabriel Teixeira, who is from Brazil. Teixeira saw parallels to the recent election in his home country, where voting is increasingly aligned with religious affiliation. Although the course focuses on the U.S., Teixeira said many of its themes are relevant globally and that comparisons of how different countries address electoral issues regularly come up in class.
Another class covered technical threats to the election and the state officials who defend them. Joanna Lydgate, CEO of the nonpartisan States United Democracy Center, joined Stephen Richer, a former elections official in Arizona’s largest county. Lydgate’s organization provides direct support to officials who run and defend elections. Richer, a Republican, broke with his party in 2021 to reverse his support of a Republican-sponsored report accusing his predecessor, a Democrat, of potential wrongdoing in the 2018 election.
In a class on protecting the election through organizing, U.S. Rep Joseph Morelle joined Leah Greenberg, co-founder of the grassroots progressive movement Indivisible Project. Morelle is a ranking member of the House Committee on House Administration, which includes in its jurisdiction federal elections. Greenberg, whose movement organizes the No Kings campaign, made the argument that hyperlocal organizing and mass mobilization are integral to the defense of democracy.
“To hear that kind of perspective that centers the importance of organizing in a law school is unique and highly valuable,” Brent-Levenstein said.
Students are able to continue the conversation with guest speakers at dinners after class. Second-year student Charlotte Densmore said the chance to meet key players in the national effort to protect elections is something that could only happen at Yale Law School.
“I feel very fortunate to have the opportunity to sit at the same table as these people and be privy to the sorts of conversations they are having, particularly about the state of democracy in the lead-up to the 2026 election,” she said.
Students expressed both alarm at how precarious fair and free elections are and a measured sense of hope for the public’s ability to do something about it. Densmore said what she learned has given her both more and less and faith in our electoral systems.
“There seem to be a lot of players trying to undermine trust in elections, but there seem to be even more people working to maintain electoral integrity,” Densmore said. “Those people give me hope.”
Third-year student Ilani Nurick is similarly left with an appreciation for the vast amount of work, carried out by thousands of people across the country, that goes into making sure elections are fair and free.
We have learned every week that the security and liberty of our elections comes down to concrete and often quite courageous actions.”
—Ilani Nurick ’27
The course has also reinforced for Nurick that no one can take election integrity for granted and that lawyers have a special role to play in protecting it. He at one point before law school worked in local politics in his home state of Washington and hopes to continue helping to protect democracy in some way after graduation.
“The only bulwark against this type of attack on our election system is people, many of whom are lawyers, standing up, actively speaking out, filing lawsuits, and litigating the baseless challenges that the Trump administration is bringing,” Nurick said. “To me, this has been a very stark reminder that one reason to go into law and become a lawyer is to ensure that we remain a country governed by the rule of law and not by the whims of a single person in D.C.”