New Essays Explore the SFALP Clinic Model and Affirmative Litigation
Two new essays in the California Law Review provide an in-depth look at how Yale Law School students have helped litigate cutting-edge public interest cases as part of the San Francisco Affirmative Litigation Project (SFALP), one of Yale Law School’s many clinical offerings.
Emma Sokoloff-Rubin ’18, SFALP’s director and a clinical lecturer in law, co-authored the essays with David Chiu, the City Attorney of San Francisco. The essays detail San Francisco’s robust affirmative litigation practice and the City’s long-standing collaboration with Yale Law School. This unique clinic model, Sokoloff-Rubin and Chiu write, accomplishes the “dual mission of expanding the capacity of public law offices and training a new generation of government lawyers,” tasks they argue are “more urgent now than ever.”
In an interview, Sokoloff-Rubin said that she and Chiu hope the essays will inspire other law schools and local governments to create their own partnerships following the SFALP model and increase the capacity of state and local governments to uphold laws protecting consumers, workers, immigrants, and the environment; fill the gap left by the federal government’s retreat from enforcement of laws protecting vulnerable communities; and respond to unlawful and unconstitutional federal actions.
Sterling Professor Emeritus of Law Heather Gerken founded SFALP with then-Deputy City Attorney Kathleen Morris in 2006 and served as faculty director throughout her time at Yale Law School. The clinic has provided students with opportunities to support affirmative litigation on behalf of the city and county of San Francisco and its residents for 20 years.
“Affirmative litigation is more important now than ever as local governments increasingly serve as the last line of defense for residents facing unprecedented threats,” said San Francisco City Attorney David Chiu in an interview. “San Francisco’s experience shows that when local governments invest in affirmative litigation, we can meaningfully protect our residents and uphold the rule of law. Our longstanding partnership with Yale Law School has been invaluable in expanding our office’s capacity and training future public lawyers who are ready to meet the challenges facing our communities. I encourage jurisdictions across the country to consider building similar collaborations.”
The first essay outlines how the San Francisco City Attorney’s Office has expanded its affirmative litigation practice in recent years. The office has used four key strategies to increase its capacity: partnering with other jurisdictions, deploying outside counsel strategically, relying on measures other than litigation, and using law students as “force multipliers.”
“Three members of the Office’s Complex and Affirmative Litigation team are alumni of the clinic, and many other alumni have taken jobs at state and local government offices doing impact litigation, inspired by their exposure to this work in law school,” Sokoloff-Rubin and Chiu write. “This clinic has significantly expanded San Francisco’s capacity to litigate affirmative cases and shaped the careers of hundreds of lawyers.”
The second essay illuminates the SFALP clinical model in more detail and shares lessons and best practices for other local governments and law schools.
As part of SFALP, students produce wide-ranging work that prepares them for the breadth of legal practice, especially at the local level. “Just this past year, students drafted complaints, requests for temporary restraining orders, memoranda of points and authorities, interrogatories, mediation memos, declarations, questions for moots, and demand letters, along with countless legal research memos,” Sokoloff-Rubin and Chiu write.
The essays detail how students working on two multi-jurisdictional challenges to illegal conditions imposed on grants from several federal agencies “assisted with research on the conditions, related executive orders, and the statutes authorizing federal agencies to disburse the grants at issue.”
For one student, Sokoloff-Rubin and Chiu write, “what began as a narrow research question on the broader structure of one of those statutes soon turned into an opportunity to see the early stages of bringing a suit in a nationwide coalition,” by participating in strategy meetings with other counties.
Sokoloff-Rubin said that clinics, externships, or partnerships could start small, like SFALP did. “You need someone at a law school that’s open to being the home for this and leading it, and you need a public law office — one that either has an established affirmative docket or is looking to establish one — that is willing to have even just a handful of lawyers put in the time to supervise students,” she explained.
“That mutual investment and excitement can drive it and ensure that the partnership takes whatever form makes sense for the partners.”
Nearly 300 Yale Law students have now participated in SFALP, creating a network of public interest lawyers working at the state and local level across the country. Sokoloff-Rubin said that current and former students have gained invaluable insight into what it’s like to work as a public lawyer for local government — a career path many hadn’t previously considered.
Susan He, a SFALP student director and 3L who joined the spring of her 1L year, said that the clinic has allowed her to experience the obstacles and creativity that inform the practical realities of government lawyering.
She became something of an expert on personal jurisdiction for her team as part of a case the City Attorney of San Francisco filed on behalf of the People of California to protect the rights of residents whose gift cards had been drained of funds, and who had little luck receiving refunds from the defendant. Her work examining analogous cases informed the team’s arguments and ultimately helped persuade the court that the similar reasoning should apply.
He also contributed to the city’s appellate brief before the Supreme Court of California, a process she said was exciting and rewarding, having worked on the case from the outset.
“The deputy city attorneys are super invested in our development, not only as law students, but also as attorneys,” He said of the mentorship and growth she’s experienced in her time with SFALP. “They are very receptive if you have a certain goal for the semester, and they pay a lot of attention to the work that you put in — they’re giving you that same amount of effort back.”
Sydney Minetta Brown, a 3L student director who has been a part of SFALP for four consecutive semesters, said that it’s been particularly meaningful for her to be part of a clinic that serves residents from her hometown.
“Yale Law School was the only school I seriously considered outside of the Bay Area because I remained committed to engaging with my hometown of San Francisco throughout law school,” she said. “The work is extra meaningful because I feel like I’m doing it not only because I’m passionate about the issues, but because I feel a profound responsibility to give back to the city that raised me and has always accepted me with open arms.”
Brown added that the opportunity to apply her passion for constitutional law to defend the people and communities she cares about has been “nothing short of extraordinary.”
“SFALP has been the vehicle that has taught me about what happens when the federal government oversteps, and how it is often the job of the state and local governments to protect their people,” she said.
“The most incredible thing is that while SFALP teaches about state and local mechanisms for protection, it gives us the opportunity to actually participate in providing it.”